Stem cell drugs: the next generation of pharmaceutical products

Abstract

Stem cells represent a new treatment option in medicine and pharmacy. Stem cells have been increasingly used for the treatment of many diseases. In fact, they have spurred a new age of medicine called regenerative medicine. In recent years, regenerative medicine has become a new revolution in disease treatment, especially with the use of stem cell drugs. Stem cell drugs refer to live stem cell based products that used as drugs for particular diseases. Unlike autologous stem cell transplantation, stem cell drugs are “off-the-shelf” products that are ready to be used without requirement of any further manipulation. This review aims to summarize some of the approved stem cell drugs, and discuss the revolution of regenerative medicine and personalized medicine. As well, the review will discuss how stem cell drugs have led to a new direction in stem cell therapy, providing a new platform for patient needs.

Introduction

Stem cells are considered as the origin of the growth and development of human beings. The capability and relative of stem cell isolation, proliferation and modification gave rise to the field of stem cell application for disease treatment. Today, there is a huge potential benefit for the use of stem cells in disease treatment (stem cell therapy). To date, there are more than 100 different diseases that have been treated with stem cell transplantation. The first application of hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) in 1950s by Donald et al. showed that stem cells could be used as drugs to treat diseases Appelbaum 2007.

Clinical applications of HSCs rapidly increased with more and more diseases treated with HSCs. From 1970s to 2000s, all HSC transplantations (HSCTs) were indicated for hematologic malignancies. In recent years, HSCTs have also been used in solid tumor treatment Kotloff et al., 2004 Rodenhuis et al., 2003 Tallman et al., 2003.

Human leukocyte antigen (HLA) matching is an important component for successful HSCT Lee et al., 2007 Petersdorf et al., 1998 Sasazuki et al., 1998. Therefore, in the initial years of HSCT, almost all cases were performed as autologous transplantation of HSCs. The stem cells were collected from bone marrow, umbilical cord blood or peripheral blood. However, autologous HSCT had some limitations, especially with regard to the quality and quantity of HSCs. More importantly, autologous HSCs have some mutations in their genome which limit their use in treating genetic diseases. To overcome these limitations, allogenic HSCT was suggested as a better platform; the use of selected HSC samples with greater quality and quantity can be controlled. In light of the demand for allogeneic HSCT, stem cell banks have been developed in several countries, such US, Japan, Korea, England and Germany Armson et al., 2015. With greater characterization of HSCs (including HLA typing), stem cells were able to be commercialized as pharmaceutical products for transplantation in the US, beginning in the 2000s. Ducord and HemaCord are two HSC drugs introduced around 2010 in the US. However, since the HLA matching ratio is very low in the human population (about 1/100,000), the business of HSC drugs has only slowly developed.

From 2012 till now, stem cell drugs have advanced with mesenchymal stem cell (MSC) based products. Similar to HSCs, in the first clinical applications of MSCs, the MSCs were administered as autologous transplantation. Indeed, HLA matching as well as immune rejection are taken into consideration before transplantation. Some allogenic transplantations of MSCs have used immunosuppressive drugs to prevent or reduce the immune rejection of grafted cells in the host. However, increasing studies have confirmed that MSCs exhibit strong immune modulation capacity that can regulate the host’s immune system; as well, they exhibit low immunogenicity compared to HSCs and other cells Ankrum et al., 2014 Hoogduijn et al., 2010 P De Miguel et al., 2012 Rasmusson, 2006.

MSCs have been transplanted into patients without immune suppression and without HLA matching with safety Hare et al., 2009 Karussis et al., 2010 Lalu et al., 2012 Wang et al., 2012. Based on such results, MSC based products have now been developed as drugs for patients with clear indications. The first MSC based stem cell drug was officially approved by the Food and Drug Agency of Canada in 2012. This drug was indicated to treat graft versus host disease (GVHD) related to HSCT.

This review aims to summarize and discuss the development and growth of stem cell drugs in medicine and pharmacy. Stem cell drug has now become a new and potentially important member of regenerative medicine. Figure 1

Download figure
Enlarge figure

Figure 1. Stem cell drugs in regenerative medicine

What are stem cell drugs?

A drug is defined as any substance other than food that when inhaled, injected, smoked, consumed, absorbed via a patch on the skin or dissolved under the tongue causes a physiological change in the body. In pharmacology, a drug (or pharmaceutical drug) is a substance used to treat, cure, prevent or diagnose a disease or to promote well-being. According to this definition, a drug must satisfy some criteria, such as having indication to treat any disease and is an off-the-shelf product. Therefore, by definition stem cell drugs are off-the-shelf products based on stem cells that are indicated to treat, cure, prevent or diagnose a disease or to promote well-being.

As off-the-shelf products, stem cell drugs are used in the allogeneic setting in stem cell transplantation. There are key differences between allogenic stem cell transplantation and stem cell drugs. The biggest difference between them is that the stem cell drug is a product, while allogenic stem cell transplantation is a procedure using the stem cell drug. Moreover, the former is approved as a drug and the latter is approved as a medical device. The details of the main differences are listed in Table 1 .

Download figure
Enlarge figure

Table 1.

Stem cell drugs: from personalized to universalized

Personalized medicine is a medical procedure that separates patients into different groups—with medical decisions, practices, interventions and/or products being tailored to the individual patient based on their predicted response or risk of disease. Stem cells offers a new approach in personalized medicine. Indeed, the definition of “personalized medicine” using stem cells has become a popular term in the last 10 years. To date, there are at least 2 approaches using stem cells in personalized medicine, as presented in. Figure 2

Download figure
Enlarge figure

Figure 2. Applications of stem cells in personalized medicine

In this review, we mainly discuss the application of stem cells in stem cell therapeutic transplantation. In stem cell transplantation, autologous stem cells from a patient are used to treat his or her disease. However, the reduction in quality and quantity of stem cells due to aging is a major limitation of this approach. However, after Yamanaka’s success with induced pluripotent stem cell production from skin fibroblasts Takahashi and Yamanaka, 2006, scientists hoped that personalized medicine would lead to greater clinical applications using autologous reprogrammed stem cells {@fig3$Induced pluripotent stem cells for personalized medicine$Fibroblasts initially isolated from skin are then reprogrammed into induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs). The iPSCs are further differentiated into specific

cell types before transplantation into patients.}. To date, this approach has faced many limitations and proven to be quite difficult. Even if all the technical difficulties and limitations related to this approach could be solved in the near future, the high price of this procedure would remain a challenge. Indeed, the process of fibroblast isolation, culture and reprogramming for clinical applications is very complex, time-consuming and expensive.

Stem cell drug for universalized medicine has become a new option in stem cell therapy. Stem cell drugs can overcome all the major limitations of autologous stem cells. Particularly, the quality, quantity and price can be controlled. While personalized medicine requires more time for development and is, in some ways, a form of medicine for the “future”, universalized medicine is more “real” in that the “off-the-shelf”, allogeneic stem cell drugs can be used for many patients.

Stem cell drugs: Drug mechanisms and properties

Stem cell drugs are mainly produced from HSCs and MSCs Table 3 . However, another kind of stem cell (limbal stem cells) can also be used to produce some products for corneal regeneration. The mechanisms of action of these stem cell drugs are different. While HSC based drugs can regenerate the hematopoietic system in treated patients (via homing and differentiation to functional cells), MSC based drugs typically target the immune system and facilitate healing at injured sites by paracrine or endocrine factors.

Download figure
Enlarge figure

Table 3.

Hematopoietic stem cell based drugs

HSCs are stem cells that can produce blood cells, including white blood cells, red blood cells and platelets, through the process of hematopoiesis. In adults, HSCs are located in the bone marrow and maintain the blood system in the body. The definition of HSC has evolved since the time HSCs were first discovered in 1961 Till and Mc, 1961. The hematopoietic tissue contains cells with long-term and short-term regeneration capacities as well as committed multipotent, oligopotent and unipotent progenitors. Nowadays, HSCs are found in and mostly isolated from bone marrow, peripheral blood and umbilical cord blood. The first successful bone marrow derived HSC transplantation was performed in 1950s by E. Donnall Thomas at Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center (Washington, USA); his work was later recognized with a Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine. Thomas infused bone marrow cells to repopulate the bone marrow and produce new blood cells. Furthermore, the first physician to perform a successful human bone marrow transplant for a disease other than cancer was Robert A. Good at the University of Minnesota in 1968. To date, HSCTs have been evaluated in a variety of malignant and non-malignant diseases. Table 2

Download figure
Enlarge figure

Table 2.

The roles of HSCs in both malignant and non-malignant diseases were determined by homing and differentiation of HSCs at bone marrow to form a new hematogenesis system. However, HSCs exert strong immunogenicity on the host immune system. Therefore, HLA matching is critical prior to HSCT. The requirement of HLA matching, however, restricts the development and advancement of HSC based stem cell drugs since there is extremely low HLA matching in the human population. Moreover, it is difficult to induce stem cell proliferation in vitro to increase cell quantity. Although umbilical cord blood seems like a good candidate for an unlimited source of HSCs, it too has challenges which limit its application, including the high cost and time for umbilical cord blood cell collection, enrichment and characterization (e.g. HLA typing).

Mesenchymal stem cell based drugs

Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) are the most popular stem cells in the human body. They are present in almost all tissues but the most common sources are bone marrow, adipose tissue, umbilical cord tissue, umbilical cord blood, and placenta. Although the MSCs from the various tissues share common properties, they also exhibit different properties, as suggested by Dominici et al. (2006) Dominici et al., 2006. Unlike other kinds of stem cells, MSCs are multifunctional; they not only differentiate into multiple cell lineages but they also produce a pool of cytokines and growth factor to execute immune modulation and promote injury healing and tissue regeneration Caplan and Dennis, 2006 Chen et al., 2008 Hocking and Gibran, 2010 Majumdar et al., 2000 Ren et al., 2008.

MSCs are favorable for clinical applications of stem cell therapy due to their multiple lineage differentiation potential. Stem cells can be differentiated in vitro or in vivo into functional cells which can replace aged or damaged cells. Indeed, some applications of stem cell therapy have entailed differentiating cells from stem cells in vitro and then transplanting them into the recipient as cellular therapy or in combination with biomaterials as tissue engineering therapy. In stem cell transplantation, scientists are also evaluating and trying to promote in vivo differentiation in the microenvironment. Ideally, stem cells can home to injured tissue sites in the body and persist for a long time. Persistence of stem cells has been observed in HSC transplantation and, in some cases, in autologous MSC transplantation. Indeed, in MSC transplantation more than 50% of grafted cells typically die in the recipient from rejection by the immune system and selection in the microenvironment. Autologous transplantation or HLA matching, therefore, are necessary to overcome the kinds of challenges.

Autologous stem cells, however, cannot be produced to mass (industrial) scale and thus stem cell based drugs are highly advantageous. As aforementioned, one important component of stem cell based drugs is the capacity for industrial scale production with similar quality from batch to batch. In most cases, MSCs were used as the source for stem cell based drugs. The two main mechanisms of therapy mediated by stem cell drugs are immune modulation and paracrine/ endocrine effects. Immune modulation is the most common mechanism of commercialized stem cell drugs generated nowadays; about 80% of stem cell drug products act via immune modulation. This means that the host immune system can be regulated by either indirect or direct interactions between stem cells and host immune cells.

Immune modulation has been observed and documented for mesenchymal stem cells from bone marrow Bai et al., 2009, adipose tissue Mello et al., 2015, umbilical cord Barcia et al., 2015 Cutler et al., 2010, and Wharton’s jelly Prasanna et al., 2010 Weiss et al., 2008. Unlike immune suppression (whereby all immune cells are inhibited in their function), immune modulation is a dynamic process whereby only some cells are affected, i.e. only some cells stimulated. By immune modulation, MSCs can effectively suppress both acute and chronic inflammation. Some stem cell drugs based on MSCs have been approved for use in certain countries and have shown their capability to exert immune modulation; one example is the first stem cell drug (Prochymal) that was evaluated for treatment of GVHD and approved by the Canadian Food and Drug Agency.

The second main mechanism of stem cell drugs relates to the growth factors produced by stem cells. MSCs can produce a pool of growth factors and cytokines which exert biological effects on other cells. MSCs can produce factors that stimulate host stem cells, inhibit apoptosis, and stimulate angiogenesis Caplan and Dennis, 2006 Chen et al., 2008 Hocking and Gibran, 2010 Majumdar et al., 2000 Ren et al., 2008. Some cytokines exert paracrine effects while others may have endocrine effects.

The future of stem cell drugs

In recent years, stem cell therapeutics studies has progressed from use of whole stem cells to components derived from stem cells. These components have included stem cell extracts, microvesicles and exosomes, all of which exhibit various biological activities. For example, exosomes from MSCs have functions similar to whole MSCs, including repair of tissue damage, suppression of inflammatory responses, and modulation of the immune system. Hu et al. (2016) demonstrated that exosomes from human adipose derived stem cells can accelerate cutaneous wound healing via optimizing the characteristics of fibroblasts Hu et al., 2016. Similar to MSCs, extra-cellular vesicles (EVs) from MSCs can modulate the immune system Burrello et al., 2016.

Exosomes from stem cells can also affect other systems and organs, such as the cardiovascular system, kidney, liver, nervous system and musculoskeletal system. In the cardiovascular system, exosomes have been suggested as cardioprotective agents Lai et al., 2010; they have been shown to have proangiogenic effects Bian et al., 2014 and involvement in reduction of apoptosis and cardiac fibrosis Feng et al., 2014. Arslan et al. (2013) showed that a single intravenous administration of exosomes was effective in enhancing cardiac function and geometry after myocardial infarction due to bioenergetics re-establishment (increased ATP production), oxidative stress reduction and pro-survival signaling activation (enhanced PI3K/Akt signaling) Arslan et al., 2013. Recently, Zhang et al. (2016) showed that MSC derived exosomes promoted cardiac stem cell proliferation in vitro Zhang et al., 2016. In kidney, studies have shown that acute kidney injury can be effectively treated with MSC based exosomes Jiang et al., 2016 Zhou et al., 2013. Moreover, MSC derived exosomes can also be used to treat fibrotic liver disease Hyun et al., 2015 Li et al., 2013. In some diseases of the musculoskeletal system, exosomes can trigger differentiation of MSCs into osteoblasts Narayanan et al., 2016 and stimulate skeletal muscle regeneration by enhancing myogenesis and angiogenesis Nakamura et al., 2015. In the nervous system, MSC derived exosomes have been evaluated in the treatment of neurological and neurodegenerative diseases; they have been shown to enhance angiogenesis and neurogenesis, reduce inflammation and improve spatial learning and sensorimotor function Kim et al., 2016 Zhang et al., 2015.

Taken together, the aforementioned discoveries suggest the dawn of a new era of stem cell therapy, i.e. stem cell drugs. Here, components (mRNA, protein and peptides) from stem cells, in microvesicles or exosomes, can be effective over whole stem cells. Certainly, the advantages of stem cell drugs include reduction of immunogenicity and easy processing, storage and delivery. Stem cells free drugs may play a potentially important and emerging role in regenerative medicine.

Conclusion

Stem cell drugs are new members of pharmaceutical medicines that are produced from stem cells. From 2012 to now, more than ten stem cell drugs have been approved in various countries for clinical applications. These products may contain live hematopoietic stem cells or mesenchymal stem cells. With their advantages such as decreased immunogenicity and ease of processing, stem cell drugs have emerged as a promising new platform in the field stem cell therapy around the world. As a new product of pharmaceutical medicine, it is anticipated that stem cell drugs will significantly contribute to both the pharmaceutical and medical industries in the near future. In clinical applications, besides the stem cell drugs which contain live and whole stem cells, new stem cell drugs containing components from stem cells (such as extracts, exosomes and vesicles) are in development and expected to be launched soon.

Lists of abbreviations

EVs: xtra-cellular vesicles; FDA: Food and Drug Angency; GVHD: graft versus host disease; HLA: Human leukocyte antigen; HPC: Hematopoietic progenitor cells; HSC: Hematopoietic stem cells; HSCT: HSC transplantations.